Brannock Port Tankage
Prepared by PortFlow with Tomas Vrede (CSM)
Summary
When we started, we agreed to work towards reduce admin load. Across the 3 outcomes we track together, average progress toward target is 43%. 2 outcomes are less than halfway to target and need joint attention. 2 figures are still an assumption and should be measured before drawing conclusions.
Observed changes are measurements and do not, on their own, show that the software caused them. Other factors are listed for each outcome. Savings appear only when explicitly confirmed by the customer.
Agreed goals vs observations
Turnaround time per vessel call
From 200 to 182 min/vessel (target 160 by 30 Jun 2027), observed 31 Oct 2026.
Source: Terminal operations log (vessel-call timestamps) (Example data) · next measurement 30 Nov 2026 (scheduled). Assumptions: Excludes calls with weather holds > 6h. Other factors: Confounders: vessel size mix, tide windows, cargo grade changes.
Port waiting time per vessel
From 90 to 76 min/vessel (target 50 by 30 Jun 2027), observed 31 Oct 2026.
Source: Vessel-call records (Example data) · next measurement 30 Nov 2026 (scheduled). Assumptions: Waiting-time reduction is NOT automatically demurrage savings. Other factors: Confounders: port congestion, pilotage availability, scheduling by charterers.
Vessel visits fully handled digitally
From 35 to 60 % (target 85 by 30 Jun 2027), observed 31 Oct 2026.
Source: Application workflow status (Example data) · next measurement 30 Nov 2026 (scheduled). Other factors: Depends on agents/surveyors also adopting digital forms.
Why you bought. What changed.
- 1 · Before purchase
Vessel calls tracked in shared Excel sheets; NoR and timesheets on paper; documents chased by phone and e-mail.
- 2 · Baseline evidence
Manual timesheet sample of 3 months (synthetic): ~210 min turnaround, ~40% visits fully digital.
- 3 · Expected outcome
Turnaround toward 160 min, most visits fully digital, fewer document-related claim disputes.
- 4 · Measured so far
Turnaround time per vessel call: 45% toward target
- 5 · How it feels today
Euro demurrage effect still unproven; operators now describe the mobile checklist as 'the way we work'.
Financial 35→25 · Operational 35→30 · Human & qualitative 10→20 · Strategic 20→25
Buying priorities and experiences have named sources and stay separate from financial savings.
Additional value (optional)
The measurable KPIs are above. Only record other value here that may matter later. Not needed to finish setup.
Advanced assessment (for a later value review) · 6 items · not verified
See the whole picture
Review financial results, day-to-day improvements and people's experience together. Qualitative benefits stay separate from money.
Financial
weight 401/1 items evidenced
A rating of progress toward financial goals. Actual amounts stay in the financial measures, not this score.
Operational & strategic
weight 353/3 items evidenced · 1 subjective
Process, compliance, safety, competitive position, flexibility, strategic milestones.
People and experience
weight 251/2 items evidenced · 1 missing (not scored) · 1 subjective
How people experience the work: ease, satisfaction, frustration, hiring and retention.
- Progress on demurrage & cost KPIsFinancialmeasuredLinked numeric KPIconfidence: medium
From: Terminal finance · Source: Agreement KPIs (see numeric layers) · Reviewed: 15 Aug 2026 · Judgement only; no euros derived here.
4 · Largely - Mobile jetty checklists replace paper formsOperational & strategicmeasuredBefore/after process documentationconfidence: high
From: Jetty operations lead · Source: Before/after checklist walkthrough (synthetic) · Reviewed: 15 Sept 2026
3 · Partly - Inspection & safety-record completenessOperational & strategicsubjectiveBuyer-confirmed observationconfidence: medium
From: HSE manager · Source: Buyer-confirmed observation, HSE review · Reviewed: 15 Oct 2026
4 · Largely - Ease of work for jetty operatorsPeople and experiencesubjectiveSurveyconfidence: medium
From: Jetty operators · Source: Pulse survey, 14 operators (synthetic) · Reviewed: 15 Aug 2026 · “Less running back to the office for signatures.”
5 · Clearly observed - Shift-handover frustrationPeople and experiencesubjectiveInterviewconfidence: low
From: Shift supervisors · Source: Interviews not yet held · Reviewed: not yet
No evidence yet - Positioning toward cargo owners as a digital terminalOperational & strategicestimatedStrategic milestoneconfidence: low
From: Terminal commercial director · Source: Commercial milestone log · Reviewed: 15 Oct 2026
3 · Partly
How the score works
- Each outcome carries a 1–5 ordinal evidence score with source, review date, confidence, stakeholder voice and a measured / estimated / subjective tag.
- Pillar score = simple mean of evidenced items. Items without evidence are excluded and counted as missing — never treated as zero or filled in.
- Blended score = importance-weighted mean of pillars with evidence; weights are renormalised over covered pillars and the result is rounded to the nearest 0.5. It is withheld below 50% weight coverage.
- Weights belong to the buyer; changing them clears the (simulated) buyer approval.
Scores summarise evidence on a 1–5 scale, not in euros. Experiences identify whose perspective they reflect.
Next actions
- Agree a measurement method and data source for “Port waiting time per vessel”.
- Agree a measurement method and data source for “Vessel visits fully handled digitally”.
- Joint working session on “Turnaround time per vessel call” — currently 45% to target.
- Review the figures and note any corrections in the Value Agreement.